Author: Kirstene Groth

  • No Body-No Parole Prisoner: Meaning of Remains

    In Armitage v Parole Board Queensland (2023) 17 QR 297, the Queensland Court of Appeal reviewed the Parole Board’s decision to issue a ‘no cooperation declaration’ for a ‘no body-no parole prisoner’, where the victim’s skeletal remains were likely destroyed by fire or animal predation. One of the key issues was the meaning of “remains”.

    Read more →

  • Grievous Bodily Harm: Disfigurement Remedied by Treatment

    In the matter of R v Lovell; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld) [2015] QCA 136, the Court of Appeal considered whether a disfigurement subsequently medically repaired is capable of amounting to ‘serious disfigurement’ under the definition of grievous bodily harm.

    Read more →

  • Aiding Death: Criminal Responsibility, Causation, and Consent

    In Carter v Attorney-General (No 2) [2014] 1 Qd R 111, the appellant, a heroin user, aided the deaths of two persons who expressed a wish to die. The Court of Appeal considered whether s 311 (aiding suicide) was a complete code, and whether killing someone with intention to kill even though that person expressed…

    Read more →

  • Mobile Phone: Misuse of a Restricted Computer

    In Cobb v Queensland Police Service (2023) 3 QDCR 123, the Court held that a mobile phone constitutes a “computer” for the purposes of s 408E of the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) — unauthorised access to a password-protected mobile phone amounted to misuse of a “restricted computer”.

    Read more →

  • Lawyer Admission: Academic Misconduct and Plagiarism

    In the matter of Re: AJG [2004] QCA 88, the applicant sought admission as a solicitor, despite having engaged in substantial academic misconduct (plagiarism), during Practical Legal Training (PLT).

    Read more →

  • False Imprisonment: No Reasonable Means of Escape

    In Burton v Davies [1953] QSR 26, the defendant’s actions of driving at high speed preventing the plaintiff from leaving the vehicle, constituted false imprisonment—as the plaintiff had no reasonable means of escape.

    Read more →

  • Sentencing Unlawful Stalking: Leaving Defamatory Notices

    In R v Morris [2010] QCA 315, the Court of Appeal considered whether the applicant’s sentence for unlawful stalking for posting defamatory notices—implicating the complainant as a murderer, was excessive.

    Read more →

  • Unlawfully Transmitting a Serious Disease (HIV): Intent

    In R v Reid [2007] 1 Qd R 64, the appellant appealed their conviction of unlawfully transmitting a serious disease (HIV) with intent to do so, contrary to s 317(b) of the Criminal Code (Qld). The appeal focused on the meaning of intent.

    Read more →

  • Negligence: Professional Discretion and Vicarious Liability

    In Queensland v Masson [2020] HCA 28, the High Court considered whether the State was liable in negligence for its paramedic’s omission to promptly administer Adrenaline to Masson, who sustained severe brain damage after an asthma attack.

    Read more →

  • Preventative Detention: No Body-No Parole Prisoner

    In this special case Cherry v Queensland [2025] HCA 141, the High Court was questioned on the constitutional validity of Queensland’s “no body-no parole” law. The plaintiff relied on the Kable principle, arguing that ss 175L and 175E of the Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) invalid. The High Court determined s 175L of the Corrective…

    Read more →